Sherwin Williams Vs. Benjamin Moore [A Clear Winner?]

Painting is the easiest way to spruce up the interiors of your home. Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore are two top brands that come to mind while searching for the best paint. Both these brands have been favorites of professional painters and DIY enthusiasts. 

Since both brands offer top-notch quality paints for your home, choosing the perfect one for your walls would be a challenging task. But, to make things easier for you, we gave a shot at some of the paints from these brands to get a clearer picture. 

We have handpicked a few of the best paints from these brands to discuss their features, what's good and what's bad to help you make an informed decision. 

So, without any further delay, let's dive right into the details. 

Sherwin Williams vs. Benjamin Moore

The walls of the home aren't painted every year, and so, the paint you choose to brighten them must be durable enough to withstand wearing, fading, and chipping. While the Sherwin Williams paints are ideal for your furniture, cabinets, and other similar tasks, the Benjamin Moore paints are perfect for coating the exteriors. 

The two powerhouse paint brands are the go-to brands for the professionals, mainly because of their top-notch quality and performance. Also interesting is the fact that these two paint brands offer both high-grade and low-grade paints to suit your needs and budgets. 

Both brands can revive the interiors of your home through their vibrant colors. They can add style and enhance the aesthetic value of your space while also preventing them against the elements. 

A Glance At Sherwin Williams 

For over 150 years, Sherwin Williams has been adding life to the living spaces of the Americans. If you want to quick-fix the walls of the office or add a dramatic haul to the bedroom, Sherwin Williams paints will transform the entire tone of your space. 

Speaking of its products, there is a whole kit and caboodle of all the painting needs of the painters. From primers, sealers, wood stains to aerosols and floor coatings, you get everything you want. Apart from paints, you get painting equipment and safety gear too. 

With their wide variety of stains, you can enhance the fences, revive furniture, repaint your cabinets, and even add vibrant hues to the plain walls. Speaking of the color palette, Sherwin Williams palettes are pretty impressive. From finest whites to warm and cool neutrals, you can lay your hands on any color. They are curated to add style and elegance to your space. 

A Glance At Benjamin Moore

Benjamin Moore's infinite color palettes will perfectly suit your taste. No matter whether you are looking for whites, neutrals, or rich marsala red, they perfectly add style and class to your space. Their colors can add exuberance to your dull living room and even liven up your bedroom. 

 

For decades, they have been delivering top-quality stains and finishes throughout the nation. What's more interesting is the coverage it offers to your walls. Speaking of durability, these paints are highly durable and protect the exteriors of your home from the elements. 

With their specialty glazes, finishes, and paints, you can overhaul the walls into spectacular pieces of art. Also, their color palettes are designed by the expert for your convenience. From their vast color collections, you can choose any color and brighten up the interiors of your space. 

Whether you are a professional painter, a DIYer, or a hobbyist, Benjamin Moore's diverse color collection is perfect for all your painting, repainting, and DIY projects. 

Sherwin Williams vs. Benjamin Moore: A Comparison

The two powerhouse paint brands of the USA, Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore, are a painter's favorite, mainly because of their premium-quality stains. And now, after getting an idea of the two brands and their products, we assume you're ready to jump right into the comparison of the two. 

Without a doubt, the paints of both these brands offer excellent coverage, shine, and durability. And so, if you are a hobbyist or a DIYer looking for the best stain for the next project, you need to know what sets the two brands apart. 

So, we will go through certain important factors you must pay attention to while choosing between the two. 

1. Paint Coverage 

Regardless of the size of your project, coverage is the most important feature while choosing any paint for your project. As such, the premium paints from Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore are slightly expensive. However, they offer exceptional coverage, hiding marks and old stains without a hitch. 

Also, whether you use rollers or brushes, the coverage remains unaffected. And, with just one coat, you're done with the painting task. As such, the professionals have been using this paint for years because of the excellent coverage it offers. 

Furthermore, the Aura product of Benjamin Moore is highly popular among the masses because of the smooth finish and even coverage that it offers to your surface. Plus, you'd also be pleased with the Regal Select paint in one primer, which offers even better coverage than the standard Regal paints. 

And, if you're going for Sherwin Williams, then you must lay hands on Sherwin Williams Cashmere as its paint and primer in one combo provide a buttery smooth application. 

Going with slightly expensive paint might be better if you are a DIYer, a hobbyist, or an enthusiast working on any painting project or repainting your living space. This is because the cheaper ones do not offer even coverage. Also, they tend to leave lines on the surface, which is not the case with these paints. 

2. Color Fan Decks And Color Files

If you've been into painting for quite some time, you must already know about the "fan deck." However, in case you don't, let us tell you. 

Put simply, they are a collection of all the shades offered by the brand. They are named so as the book spreads out like the fan. Fun, isn't it?

Both the Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore offer a fan deck that consists of paint chips of the shades offered by the brand. We've got our hands on both the fan decks, and we can say that both of them offer a wide range of hues for you to choose from. However, the Sherwin Williams one stands out in contrast to Benjamin Moore's. 

The Sherwin Williams fan deck is the most versatile as it consists of over 2,000 colors which is pretty impressive. Moreover, it features sheen, gloss, and even gray-shade primer chips. This makes it easy for you to understand the texture and shade without the hassles of visiting a store. 

Benjamin Moore's color fan deck is curated by the experts. They offer around 5 fan decks ranging from subtle and sophisticated hues, airy pastels, and neutrals to dramatic deeps and bold hues. With such a diverse range, you can choose whichever shade you want. 

There is no doubt that the color palettes of both brands are manifold. However, we've seen customers prefer Sherwin Williams over Benjamin Moore because of its myriad shades. 

Whether you should choose Sherwin Williams or Benjamin Moore's fan deck depends entirely upon your needs and preferences. However, if you are a professional painter, you must go for the Sherwin Williams fan deck. And Benjamin Moore's fan deck is excellent for all the novices, DIYers, and hobbyists. 

3. Quality

Whether you are looking for a quick fix or want to give a complete makeover to the interiors, a paint of high quality can provide the much-needed finish to your surface. The market is saturated with cheaper paints of inferior quality, which are prone to peeling and chipping. Also, they leave a banding effect on the surfaces. 

But none is the case if you go for premium quality paints. So, a top-notch quality paint will be the best option for your next renovation project. As such, the high-grade paints from Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore are slightly expensive; they provide a smooth and even finish to your surface. 

Although you'd notice the quality of both the paints is similar to each other, most people prefer Benjamin Moore over Sherwin Williams. So, in terms of quality, both these brands are equally good, and you can use either one for your projects. 

Be it Sherwin Williams or Benjamin Moore, you may use whichever appeals to you, for they both are premium quality paints and will provide a smooth finish. 

4. Durability

Both Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore's paints are highly durable. They are resistant to wearing, chipping, and flaking. If painted on the exteriors, such as fences, they protect the surface from the elements. 

If you are planning to go for Sherwin Williams, you must try out the Duration Home Interior Acrylic Latex paint, for they are highly durable. This would be perfect for adding durability to the walls of your home. 

Also, if you are looking to add durability to the trims and cabinets, you must try the Emerald urethane trim enamel. It will provide the much-needed durability to your surfaces, making it resistant to wear and tear. Apart from this, SuperPaint and ProClassic would also be excellent options to add durability to furniture, cabinets, and walls. 

But, if you plan to use Benjamin Moore for your next renovation project, Aura is a must-try, for it is the most sophisticated line of paints. It is best for those spaces which will be frequently cleaned for it offers excellent durability. 

So, as far as durability is concerned, both Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore are similar. However, people tend to prefer Benjamin Moore over Sherwin Williams because of its improved durability. 

5. Performance

You don't paint your home every now and then. So, you might as well choose a high-performing paint. Both brands are on the same terms as far as performance is concerned. While talking about performance, coverage, and touch-up are the two areas you need to consider. The number of coats you need to cover your surface is known as coverage. The better the brand you invest in, the fewer coats you will require. 

Moreover, cheap quality paints offer nothing but poor coverage. So, it's better to invest in a top-notch brand to ensure efficient performance. 

And, the next thing to consider is touch-ups. If, after a few years, your paint begins to flake or chip away, the brands offer touch-ups. Of course, you'd want a good touch-up that will blend seamlessly with the previous coating and not a bad one that leaves marks. So, you must invest in high-end paints for flawless touch-ups. 

In terms of performance, both Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore are outstanding. In fact, it is the go-to paint for all professional painters and amateurs. However, while testing, we found out that Benjamin Moore surpassed Sherwin Williams because it is super easy to apply, offers more durability, and is easy to clean. 

So, if you are a novice and have not much experience with paints, Benjamin Moore is the best to get your hands on. However, for professionals, Sherwin Williams is an excellent choice. 

6. Accessibility

Getting your hands on Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore isn't difficult. As they are popular paint brands, you can easily buy them from the local stores. However, there's a slight difference in ownership. Sherwin Williams stores are locally owned, while Benjamin Moore has authorized dealer outlets. 

The novices just have to google outlets near them and walk into their favorite brands' store to get their hands on the pastel or neutrals to create their masterpiece. 

7. Affordability

If you're wondering which of the two brands comes with an affordable price tag, then let us tell you that there isn't much of a difference. 

Benjamin Moore's one paint can of 2 gallons will cost you around between 45 to 50 dollars. But, we've noticed Sherwin Williams is slightly on the expensive side. So, if you are looking for an affordable option, Benjamin Moore is perfect. But if your client demands Sherwin Williams coating, you might as well shell out a few extra bucks. 

Also, the prices fluctuate every now and then. So, it is best to keep an eye on them so that you can have a great deal when the prices are low. And, if you want to pinch pennies, you can keep an eye on their space for deals and discounts. 

Sherwin Williams Paints vs. Benjamin Moore Paints

Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore are the two powerhouse brands providing quality paints for all your needs. In terms of quality and performance, both brands are on cut-throat competition as both ensure even coverage and a smooth finish to whatever project you have at hand

However, you won't buy paints from both brands. So, to make things easier for you, we'll now compare a few popular products from Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore to help you gain more clarity so that you pick the best. 

So, without any further ado, let's dive right into the deets. 

1. Benjamin Moore White Dove vs. Sherwin Williams Alabaster

If you're looking for the white paint to brighten up your space, then both these paints from the two brands are excellent. These high-quality paints create a perfect backdrop for all your masterpieces. 

When it comes to appearance, they look pretty similar to each other. But, after testing both, we can say that the Benjamin Moore White Dove gets an edge over Sherwin Williams Alabaster due to its enhanced durability. 

In comparison to the white dove paint, which is easy to spread and clean once dried, the alabaster paint dries rapidly and provides a glossy surface. Although both the paints are just about the same price, the Benjamin Moore provides an excellent value for your money if you're looking for a 2 gallon can. 

The Benjamin Moore white dove is the best for novices, amateurs, and DIYers, while the alabaster paint is excellent for professionals. 

2. Benjamin Moore Ben vs. Sherwin Williams Opulence

Benjamin Moore Ben offers excellent coverage to your walls, flawlessly hiding all the marks and stains. That being said, it comes with an expensive price tag. But if you're simply planning to repaint your bedroom, Sherwin Williams opulence will be perfect. 

Both of these paints come with the same coverage, and so just with 2 coatings, you're done. But while testing the two paints, we came across the fact that Sherwin Williams spreads quickly with a roller and provides smooth walls than the Ben by Benjamin Moore. Because of its smoothness, you are able to roll the walls in a breeze. 

It is true not a lot of enthusiasts or hobbyists pay attention to this. But, if you are a professional in this field, you know how important this factor is. If you are a DIYer, you'll love the Sherwin Williams Opulence because of its buttery smooth application. 

3. Benjamin Moore Regal Select vs. Sherwin Williams Cashmere

If you have a large-scale project at hand, we assume you're in quest of a variety of paint offering different finishes. As such, the Regal Select and Cashmere by the two powerhouse brands come in a variety of finishes to meet your needs. 

Although both the paints are of premium quality, the Regal Select is a cut above Cashmere. And this is why it costs a few bucks more than Cashmere. Also, the Regal Select is easier to spread, clean, and is highly durable than the Cashmere. 

So, if quality is your major concern, Benjamin Moore is a better bet any day. However, if it isn't available in the local store, you can order it directly from their website. 

4. Benjamin Moore Advance vs. Sherwin Williams ProClassic

If you are confused between Benjamin Moore Advance and Sherwin Williams ProClassic, then let us ease your confusion. We tested both the products and found Benjamin Moore's Advance paint was of better quality than the Sherwin Williams ProClassic. The novices, DIYers, and hobbyists can easily use this paint, for it is easy to spread. 

Also, you do not have to recoat the surface to ensure an even finish, thanks to its thick consistency. Furthermore, using a sprayer will provide a better sheen to your surface. 

We also noticed that the Advance paint did not emit as much odor as the ProClassic paint, thanks to its low VOC. So, you can work for long hours without worrying about headaches. 

However, the ProClassic's odor isn't very strong. It has some weird plastic kind of smell which disappears in a day. Simply put, the Advance paint is almost odorless while the ProClassic emits an odor. 

As for the quality, the Advance paint is of much better quality than the ProClassic. Overall, both the paints offer a smooth finish and excellent coverage. Also, it is relatively easy on your pockets. 

If you are sensitive to strong smells, Benjamin Moore's Advance paint will be the best for you. But if you can withstand odors and want to freshen up your room with a subtle glow, Sherwin Williams is the best option. 

Why Prefer Sherwin Williams?

Sherwin Williams is without a doubt world's most renowned brand offering stains and coating for various purposes. What catches our attention is that it offers over 2000 colors to choose from to get what you want. Whether you are looking for brighter white or crabby apple, Sherwin Williams has it all. Also, you can get shades customized and paint the interiors with your favorite hues. 

You'll love the buttery smooth application and excellent coverage offered by their paints. Whether there are marks or stains on the walls, Sherwin Williams covers all the imperfections flawlessly. Also, they furnish your home with elegance, thanks to their premium quality. 

Furthermore, their stain-blocking paints cover the previous stains flawlessly on your walls. And Sherwin Williams paints are super easy to clean and can also withstand fading. Plus, if you’re confused regarding the shades, they've got experts to help you out. 

Why Prefer Benjamin Moore?

Whether revamping a client's house or renovating your own space, Benjamin Moore's wide variety of shades will perfectly add life to your space. Their Natura range of paint is odorless because it contains no VOCs. You can ensure long working hours without posing any threat to your health. 

They are the painter's favorite because they can be easily spread using rollers. You can clean them easily using water and mild soap. What's interesting is that they offer excellent coverage. Simply apply 2 coats, and your job is done. Moreover, you'll love their vibrant hues, which add class, elegance, and style to the homes.

Furthermore, whether you are looking for a quick fix or dramatic overhaul, you can do anything without costing a fortune. Also, their high-pigmentation technology doesn't let the color fade, ensuring they last really long. So, they are highly durable. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Since both the brands are pretty identical in terms of performance, coverage, and finish, we understand you might have some queries regarding the two. So, we'll be answering a handful of the most commonly asked questions. Let's have a look. 

1. Which Is The Better Brand For Painting The Exteriors?

Although both the brands offer premium quality paints, we recommend Sherwin Williams for painting the exterior surfaces. You can go for Sherwin Williams Exterior Acrylic Latex, for they are highly durable. Their thick consistency offers excellent coverage to your surfaces. Use them once, and they will last for years. 

Also, another amazing product for your exteriors is the Super paint from Sherwin Williams, which offers excellent protection against the elements and also withstands peeling and fading. Also, it is resistant to mildew and dirt. 

2. Which Company's Paint is The Best?

As it is, it all depends upon the user's needs and preferences. However, in our opinion, Benjamin Moore edges over Sherwin Williams, mainly because of its enhanced durability. 

They are easy to apply, resistant to fading, and chipping and have a quick dry time compared to Sherwin Williams. Also, they are the go-to paints for professionals. 

3. Which Brand Is Best For DIY works?

For a DIY person, Benjamin Moore would prove to be an excellent option. Its thick consistency provides excellent coverage. You can use a roller or a brush and easily apply it to your walls. You also don't need to worry about the paint running down due to its thick consistency. So, for a beginner or a DIYer, this is an excellent option.

Summing It Up

When it comes to paints, both Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore are the best in the US. 

While Benjamin Moore is more popular among the novices and DIYers, Sherwin Williams is much preferred by professionals. 

They are pretty identical to each other in terms of performance, coverage, durability, and accessibility. Both brands indeed manufacture similar quality products, and so it isn't easy to pick a winner.  Ultimately, it boils down to your needs and preferences. Honestly, in our opinion, it is a tie.

With that, we come to the end of our guide. Hopefully, you will be able to pick the correct one for your needs. Let us know which brand you'd opt for your painting tasks. 

Till then, happy painting!