Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker: The 7 Best Makers to Get

Hand-cranked machines are a classic and reliable option for producing homemade ice cream. This is the old-fashioned way to make ice cream, ensuring a high-quality dessert.

Not only are hand crank options affordable, but they also produce some of the best high-quality ice cream recipes.

They are a great activity that can entertain the whole family for hours. Plus, there's something about the taste and quality of the cold ice cream you created in the tub.

So, sit back, grab a spoon, and let me help you in your search to find the best hand-crank ice cream maker on the market. It's sure to be a wild (and delicious) ride!

Listed below are the 5 best hand-crank ice cream makers from our list:

• Immergood Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker: Offers a large-capacity 8-quart canister with a seamless crank, but the noise level and steep price may be concerns for some.
• Donvier 837450 Manual Ice Cream Maker: A budget-friendly option, the Donvier 837450 is easy to use with a compact design and doesn't require salt or ice, however, it offers a small capacity and may take longer to freeze ice cream.
• Elite Gourmet EIM-506 6-quart Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Maker: With the versatility to create various frozen treats, this ice cream maker provides easy clean-up, but it can be noisy and takes longer to freeze compared to other machines.
• AMERIHOME ICM6C 6-Quart Old Fashion Ice Cream Maker: This hybrid model ice cream maker offers two modes of use, allowing you to switch easily between hand-cracking or electric power, but it may prove to be noisy and take a while to freeze.
• Lehman's Amish-Made Hand-Crank Ice Cream Freezer: Perfect for larger batches, this ice cream freezer can handle up to 8 quarts at a time and offers durability, but may prove to be heavy, bulky, and difficult to clean.

1. Best Overall: Immergood Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker

When making ice cream, having the right machine to produce the dessert can make all the difference.

While many types of ice cream machines are on the market, hand-cranked ice cream machines are a classic and reliable option that has been around for generations.

The Immergood Ice Cream Maker is one of the best hand-cranked ice cream makers on the market, and I have had the pleasure of using it recently.

With an 8-quart canister, this ice cream maker can produce enough ice cream for a crowd.

The crank is smooth and easy to turn, and the tub has clear measurement markings to make it easy to add ingredients. The clear lid allows you to peek inside while churning.

From the data gathered thru personal experience, I can confidently say it is the best option for anyone looking to produce their ice cream at home.

However, there are some downsides to it. For example, this model is one of the more expensive hand-cranked ice cream makers on the market, but I think it's worth the investment.

The crank can be quite loud, which might be a problem if you make ice cream in front of a crowd or with guests.

Despite all that, with its sturdy construction, large capacity, and ease of use, this hand crank machine is the standout product you should get!

2. Best Value: Donvier 837450 Manual Ice Cream Maker

If you are in search of the best value ice cream machine, the Donvier 837450 is a great option for anyone who wants to make their own ice cream.

The Donvier 837450 is one of the most affordable hand-cranked ice cream makers on the market, making it a great option for those on a budget.

It is affordable and easy to use and produces consistently delicious desserts every time, making it the best hand crank ice cream maker without breaking the bank.

The simple design of this ice cream maker makes it easy to use, with no electricity or complicated parts to worry about. The compact size of the Donvier 837450 makes it easy to store and transport, making it a great option for taking to parties or family gatherings.

If you've ever used a manual ice cream maker, you already know you require salt and ice to get it going. But this Donvier model is an exception! No sale of ice is needed!

There are some things to note before buying this product. With a capacity of just 1 quart, the Donvier 837450 may not be the best option for large families or groups.

The short crank handle can make it difficult to turn the dasher, especially when the mixture starts to freeze.

Compared to other machines, the Donvier 837450 may take longer to freeze the mixture, which can be frustrating if you're in a hurry.

The maker provides you with a recipe booklet that has a good number of recipes. Additionally, you can see inside because the canister lid is transparent.

3. Best Versatile: Elite Gourmet EIM-506 6-quart Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Maker

The Elite Gourmet EIM-506 6-quart Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Maker is an amazing machine for those who want to make various frozen treats, not just ice cream.

This hand crank machine can produce ice cream, yogurt, sorbet, and other frozen goods in the same tub. Just add ice and rock salt to start churning! It's that easy!

The plastic tub and dasher are easy to clean, making this appliance very low maintenance. Having an appliance have easy cleaning access is a deal maker for many!

I've been using this device for just a few months, but I've been impressed with its performance and versatility. The crank on the machine is slow, but the taste is amazing.

Not every product is perfect, so even this machine has its mishaps. The loud noise produced by the motor and crank handle can be annoying. This machine can take longer to freeze the mixture than other hand-crank ice cream makers.

If you're looking for a multifunctional hand-crank ice cream maker that can also double as an ice crusher, the Elite Gourmet EIM-506 is worth considering.

4. Best Hybrid: AMERIHOME ICM6C 6-Quart Old Fashion Ice Cream Maker

The AMERIHOME ICM6C 6-Quart Old Fashion Ice Cream Maker is a game-changer in the world of dessert machines.

This hybrid model is the best on the market. You can easily switch between the two modes with old-fashioned hand-cranking and modern electric power.

The electric motor and old-fashioned hand-cranking combination offer a unique and nostalgic experience.

With a 6-quart wide pine tub, you can make large batches to share with family and friends.

The clear view lid allows you to monitor the ice cream-making process without interrupting it. In addition, the high-quality aluminum canister and heavy-duty plastic bucket ensure long-lasting use.

It's a must-have for any dessert lover who wants to enjoy delicious ice cream without the hassle of manual cranking but with the option to do so. Just add ice and salt to go.

There are things to look out for. As with many appliances, the AMERIHOME ICM6C can be quite loud. Additionally, it can take some time to freeze the ice cream mixture to the desired consistency depending on the recipe and temperature.

This device is versatile, easy to use, and can produce smooth and creamy ice cream, making it the best hand crank ice cream machine.

5. Best for Large Batches: Lehman's Amish-Made Hand-Crank Ice Cream Freezer

Lehman's Amish-Made is the perfect solution for those who want to make large quantities of ice cream. The 8-quart capacity is larger than most hand-cranked ice cream machines, allowing you to make more ice cream in one batch.

This machine has high-quality stainless steel canisters and a sturdy wooden bucket.

This hand-crank machine is Amish-made and designed to last for years. It can make up to 8 quarts in one go, making it ideal for family gatherings, parties, or events.

Add your ice cream mixture to the canister, add ice and salt to the wooden bucket, and start cranking! The process is straightforward and enjoyable.

While this product has amazing features, the machine's weight and size can make it difficult to move around, but this is a necessary trade-off for its large capacity.

The machine's parts can be challenging to clean thoroughly, especially if the mixture has hardened.

Regardless, compared to other machines, this machine has a larger capacity, making it the best maker for those who want to make delicious ice cream in bulk.

6. Best Wooden: Country Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker

Country Hand Crank is the perfect addition to any kitchen, providing a unique experience for those who love making desserts.

This wooden hand-crank machine stands out from its competitors with its sturdy and durable construction, making it the best wooden hand-crank ice cream maker.

The hand crank turns smoothly and effortlessly, making it easy to churn up a batch without hand strain or fatigue.

One of the more disadvantages points of this product is its need for high maintenance. Unlike other hand-crank ice cream makers, the wooden exterior requires more care to prevent damage or warping.

In addition, while the hand crank turns smoothly, the metal can make noise against the wooden frame during operation.

The rustic appearance of the Country Hand Crank makes it a charming addition to any family kitchen while offering top-notch functionality.

7. Best For Small Spaces: Donvier Half-Pint Ice Cream Maker

Donvier Half-Pint Ice Cream Maker is a compact and convenient appliance for small spaces. The Donvier is the best option for those with limited kitchen space.

This hand-cranked machine is incredibly easy to clean, even for beginners; the Donvier Half-Pint is a perfect size.

You and your family can spend hours of fun making ice cream in the tub, taking turns moving the crank, and making the tasty dessert in the machine.

Its small size makes it ideal for people who want to make their dessert at home without taking up too much counter space.

However, the Donvier Half-Pint has a small capacity and can only make a small amount. Due to its smaller size, churning the mixture to the desired consistency may take longer.

The Donvier Half-Pint requires the inner bowl to be pre-frozen before use, which may take up valuable freezer space.

Although this product has its fair share of mishaps, it is still worth the investment!

What is the Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker?

This section provides a comprehensive examination of top-quality hand-crank ice cream makers. The comparison table below offers a systematic evaluation of these machines, taking into account crucial attributes such as material, capacity, weight, dimensions, and warranty.

How Can You Make Great Homemade Ice Cream?

Making creamy ice cream can be a fun and delicious activity. Here are the basic steps to making this timeless dessert:

1. Prepare the mixture: Combine your ingredients in a saucepan and heat until hot but not boiling. You can use various ingredients like milk, cream, and sugar.
2. Chill the mixture: Once it is prepared, let it cool to room temperature, then chill it in the refrigerator until it reaches 40°F (4°C) or lower.
3. Churn the mixture: Pour the chilled mixture into your appliance and churn. Some machines require ice and rock salt before operating.
4. Freeze the ice cream: Once it has reached a soft-serve consistency, transfer it from the bowl to a container and freeze it in the freezer.
5. Enjoy: Scoop your dessert into bowls or cones and enjoy!

Remember to have fun with your ice cream-making and experiment with different flavors and ingredients to create unique recipes.

What Are Factors to Consider When Buying an Ice Cream Maker?

When considering buying an ice cream maker, there are several factors to remember. Here are some of the most important factors to consider:

1. Type: There are two types of machines. Hand cranks require you to crank them by hand, while electric ones use a motor to churn. Consider which type is most convenient for you.
2. Capacity: Consider how much ice cream you want to make at once. These appliances come in various sizes, ranging from 1 to 6 quarts.
3. Ease of use: Look for a machine that is easy to use and clean. Some models have more parts to assemble. Others do not need ice or salt, making them easier to clean.
4. Speed: Some ice cream machines can produce and freeze faster than others. If speed is important, look for models that can make desserts quickly.
5. Brand: Some top brands include Buffalo Tools, Immergood, and Donvier. Each brand has unique qualities and strengths, so research is important.
6. Price: Ice cream machines can vary greatly, so consider your budget and how often you use the machine.
7. Additional features: Some machines have features like making frozen yogurt. These features, of course, come with a higher price tag.

What Is the Difference Between an Electric and a Hand Crank?

With hand crank machines, you don’t need to break the bank on expensive equipment, and you get the satisfaction of making your own ice cream with your own two hands.

While an electric ice cream maker with an electric motor requires electricity, hand crank machines rely solely on your own upper body strength.

Electric models can typically produce larger quantities more quickly, while hand crank models may require more time and effort.

Another notable difference is the quality. Many believe that hand-cranked produces a better texture, as the slower churning allows for more air, resulting in richer ice cream.

However, electric machines can also produce high-quality results with the added convenience of automation.

Ultimately, the quality of desserts will depend on the specific machine and recipe.

What Are the Top Brands for an Ice Cream Maker?

Some top brands are White Mountain, Buffalo Tools, and Immergood. These are known for producing high-quality machines that consistently make delicious desserts.

How Long Does It Take To Make Ice Cream With a Manual Ice Cream Maker?

Making a batch typically takes 30-45 minutes of churning with a manual ice cream maker.

However, the actual time can vary based on the specific recipe, the ingredients’ temperature, and the appliance’s efficiency.

How Long Does Handmade Ice Cream Last?

When stored properly, homemade ice cream lasts about 2-3 months in the freezer. However, the exact shelf life can depend on the ingredients used and the storage conditions.

Can You Reuse Ice and Rock Salt for Ice Cream?

Yes, you can reuse ice and rock salt if the mixture has not melted. Simply remove the excess water and add more ice and salt before using it again.

However, it is important to note that reusing the mixture may affect the freezing process and the quality of the dessert.

Is Handmade Ice Cream Good for Kids’ Birthdays?

Handmade ice cream can be a great treat for kids’ birthdays! It allows for the customization of flavors and mix-ins and can be a fun activity for kids.

However, it’s important to consider any dietary restrictions or allergies when selecting ingredients.

A perfect treat for a kid’s birthday party is none other than hotdogs. To know more, check out the Best Hot Dog Rollers.

Is Handmade Desserts a Good Gift for Loved Ones?

Yes, handmade desserts can be a great gift for loved ones, especially those who appreciate homemade and personalized gifts.

Handmade desserts allow you to customize flavors and ingredients to suit the recipient’s preferences, making it a thoughtful and unique gift.

A great handmade dessert to make is chocolate! However, you can be creative and make hot chocolate instead as an alternative for dessert. If you want to have a good hot chocolate maker, then check out the best hot chocolate maker you can find.

You can also spend quality time making the ice cream together, creating memories and bonding over a shared experience.

If you want to know more about gifting your loved ones, check out the Best Hot Chocolate Gift Sets.