Subscribe

[mc4wp_form id="87729"]
x

Homesthetics

11 Best Broiler Pan of 2021 [Reviewed & Buyer’s Guide]

Preparing for the barbecue. Skewers of chicken on black plate. Marinated in pepper with lemon and garlic. raw chicken legs

Disclaimer | This article may contain affiliate links, this means that at no cost to you, we may receive a small commission for qualifying purchases.

If you love cooking, then selecting the right broiler pan for your recipes might be a bit of a headache!

Of the many instruments used in a kitchen, the broiler pan is quite a necessity. It is a hollow enamel plate that you use when you have to collect the juice and fat from roasted meat and fish.

One of the advantages of using a broiler pan is that you don’t need to use much oil, giving you a healthier and cheaper cooking instrument.

So, if you want to go in for a healthier cooking option, a broiler pan is what you need. And today, we’ll help you opt for the best broiler pan.

Just read on to know more!

Best Broiler Pan

Document
IMAGE PRODUCT DETAILS
Our Top PickOur Top Pickhstcstbl-table__imageGeneral Electric WB48X10056
  • Includes grill as well as a bottom pan
  • Made of nonstick material
  • Weighs just 0.01 lbs
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
hstcstbl-table__imageRange Kleen BP106X
  • 2-piece pan allows for regular food prepping
  • Works well for outdoor cooking
  • Made of solid porcelain
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
hstcstbl-table__imageGranite Ware 0513-2
  • Has a non-porous surface
  • Product is PFOA and PTFE-free
  • Has a porcelain enamel surface
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
hstcstbl-table__imageP&P CHEF 8541881358
  • Solid, stainless steel material
  • Non-toxic coating
  • Comes in metallic silver color
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
hstcstbl-table__imageNorpro 273
  • Stainless steel pan with two pieces
  • Perforated top absorbs excess oil from food
  • Compact but sturdy
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
hstcstbl-table__imageBackcountry SKL-200
  • Comes with deep ribs on the surface
  • Made of cast iron
  • Comes with non-sticking features
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
hstcstbl-table__imageNordic 41831
  • Includes broiling rack and baking pan
  • Comes with nonstick features
  • Made from aluminized steel
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
hstcstbl-table__imageTeamFar 8541905117
  • Made of stainless steel
  • No other chemical coating on the surface
  • Smooth, rounded edges
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
hstcstbl-table__imageSmart Choice 55926
  • Made of aluminum
  • Has nonstick porcelain coating
  • Comprises of broiler tray and dripping pan
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
hstcstbl-table__imageG&S PB7992
  • Three-piece set cookware
  • Made of professional-grade steel
  • Includes extra Teflon layer
VIEW LATEST PRICE →

Raw chicken legs in a frying pan on a wooden table. Meat ingredients for cooking. Top view. Closeup.

  1. General Electric WB48X10056

General Electric is well known for its home appliances. Like most of its products, the WV48X10056 is a formidable cooking instrument. It works well for roasting larger meat and for the occasional baking as well.

GE WB48X10056 Genuine OEM Broiler Pan for GE...
  • The GE Appliances WB48X10056 Broiler Pan is a genuine OEM...
  • Replacement GE Appliances Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan...
  • GE Appliances WB48X10056 Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan...
  • High quality GE Appliances OEM WB48X10056 Range/Stove/Oven...

Why Did We Like It?

The WB48X10056 has a lot of features that make it perfect for the kitchen. It has a large surface that makes it perfect for cooking larger foods like turkey or prepping meals for an entire week.

Also, we loved that the core is manufactured with solid, industrial-grade steel, meaning it is quite durable and lasts long. The pan’s coating is made of nonstick porcelain. It is ideal for speedier cooking because the material distributes heat evenly across the pan.

That’s not all; we loved the serrated upper piece. This helps in draining the fat and oil in your meats far more efficiently than any other material. If you’re health-conscious, then this broiler pan works well for your cooking. Lastly, it is also dishwasher-safe, making it easier to clean.

What Could’ve Been Better?

While we found a lot of highs for the pan, we did find a couple of lows. One aspect we felt was a hazard is the edge. It’s razor-sharp, and you need to be careful around it. We also discovered that the nonstick coating does not last as long as we expected.

Pros
  • Durable and lasts long
  • Nonstick porcelain allows for quicker cooking
  • Drains fats effortlessly
  • Dishwasher-safe and easy to clean
  • The large surface allows for bulk cooking
Cons
  • Nonstick coating does not last for long
  • Razor-sharp edges can be harmful
  1. Range Kleen BP106X

Range Kleen is another brand that is quite popular when it comes to home appliances. The BP106X is another broiler pan that allows for effortless cooking. The broiler pan works quite well, especially for bulk cooking.

Sale
Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan 12.75...
  • COOKING DONE RIGHT: Make the perfect meals with the help of...
  • MADE FROM HIGH QUALITY MATERIALS: Heavy-duty porcelain on...
  • GOOD FEATURES FOR BROILING AND BAKING: The grate of the...
  • COOK AND CLEAN WITH EASE: The materials are easy to clean...

Why Did We Like It?

There’s a lot to like about the BP106X. First of all, we loved that the pan is relatively light. This means that removing food from the oven isn’t a hectic task. We also loved how easy to clean and dishwasher-safe it is.

Besides, the pan is capable of withstanding high temperatures. This means that cooking anything that needs high heat is not a problem. Along with that, we loved that the porcelain material on it allows for even heat distribution.

Along with all these interesting factors, another reason to root for the BP106X is that it is perfect for the health-conscious. While cooking meat, the fats and oil drip into the pan underneath.

What Could’ve Been Better?

We’ll be honest – while the pan is quite suitable for cooking a lot of food, we found a minor flaw. It is relatively small, especially when you compare it to other pans in this category. This makes cooking large meats like turkey a tad difficult.

Pros
  • Withstands high temperatures
  • Lightweight and easy to handle
  • Dishwasher-safe and easy to clean
  • Works well for fat-free cooking
Cons
  • Relatively smaller than a regular pan
  1. Granite Ware 0513-2

The Granite Ware 0513-2 is very much a multi-purpose tool. It is ideal for cooking almost anything. It’s common to see the pan used for barbecuing or simply baking. The grill rack and the bottom pan are quite useful for day-to-day cooking and meal prep.

Sale
Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan, 3-Piece Set
  • Granite Ware Bake and Broil set is Made in Mexico
  • Carbon Steel core is more energy efficient, browns better...
  • Porcelain enamel surface is an inert, non-porous and...
  • Our Roasters and Baking pans have no PFOA, PTFE or other...

Why Did We Like It?

The 0513-2 is an excellent broiler pan for a number of reasons. One reason we really loved this pan is that it is made of a carbon steel core. The material is quite solid and durable enough. It also is made to allow even heat distribution that cooks food well.

Cooking any food in the 0513-2 is ideal. The pan has been made to allow excessive oils and fats to be collected in the dripping pan. This means that if you’re eating healthy, this broiler pan is definitely a good pick.

Along with the heat distribution and healthy cooking, we loved that the pan is lightweight and non-sticky. Thanks to its non stick feature, you also don’t need to worry about the pan being difficult to clean.

What Could’ve Been Better?

We loved a lot of things about the 0513-2. However, there was a problem we did find with the pan. We noticed that the pan seems to get damaged when too much heat is used in it. You need to be careful while using the product to ensure that doesn’t happen.

Pros
  • Allows for even heat distribution
  • Carbon-steel core allows durability and efficiency
  • Useful for fat-free cooking
  • Comes with a nonstick feature
Cons
  • Too much heat can cause damage
  1. P&P CHEF 8541881358

The P&P CHEF Broiler Pan is unlike any of the other pans we’ve reviewed so far. It is made of high-quality stainless steel and is suited for smaller batches of cooking. Its mirror finish and compact size make it perfect for day-to-day cooking.

Toaster Oven Pan with Rack Set, P&P CHEF Stainless Steel...
  • 【HEALTHY】The toaster oven pan is made of high quality...
  • 【HEAVY DUTY】The broiler pan is solid constructed by...
  • 【EASY CLEAN】Deep full sides around help this toaster...
  • 【CRAFT】Smooth edge without rough spot, Mirror finish...

Why Did We Like It?

The P&P CHEF is a pan unlike any of the others we’ve reviewed so far. The pan is made of stainless steel, which we think helps in cooking food easier. We also loved that with stainless steel, the material is made of non-toxic material, unlike Teflon that could be harmful in the long run.

In addition to this, the heat is distributed evenly in the tray, providing you well-cooked food. The pan is also easy to clean, even if it is stainless steel. This is also due to the fact that the product is dishwasher-safe.

We really loved the product’s compact size. Stainless steel means it is sturdier than other nonstick pans. But on this product, sturdiness is not a disadvantage. Instead, the product’s size means it fits any ovens easily.

What Could’ve Been Better?

The product is entirely satisfactory in many ways, and there’s much we loved about it. However, we found that this product had a minor disadvantage. While its size is admirable, it does make larger batches of cooking impossible, especially for meats like turkey. You might need a larger broiling pan for that.

Pros
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher-safe
  • Made of non-toxic material
  • Stainless steel body for easier cooking
  • Compact and easy fit for any ovens
Cons
  • Cannot be used for bigger batches of cooking
  1. Norpro 273

The Norpro 273 is one of the higher-end broiler pans on the list. It comes from a manufacturer well known for quality kitchenware. The broiler pan, like most products from Norpro, is made to suit your kitchen needs.

Norpro Broil/Roast Pan Set, 12 inches, One Color
  • Measures: 12" x 9" x 1.5" / 30.5cm x 23cm x 4cm
  • This two-piece stainless steel broiler pan with perforated...
  • Made of stainless steel for strength and durability. Easy to...
  • Perfect for individual or two person servings.

Why Did We Like It?

The Norpro 273 has plenty of reasons to be popular. One of them is that its two-pack set serves dual functions. You can use it for broiling as well as roasting. The perforated parts of the top layer allow oils to be drained effortlessly.

The easy oil draining feature makes this pan a requirement for anyone wanting to eat healthily. We also loved that the pan is quite durable. This is solely due to its stainless steel body. Cooking with the pan is also easy because the stainless steel allows even heat distribution.

Besides this, another reason we loved the Norpro 273 is due to its easy clean feature. Even though the pan is not nonstick, cleaning with it is not difficult, either manually or with a dishwasher.

What Could’ve Been Better?

While the broiler pan is dishwasher safe and made of strong stainless steel, we did find a problem with it. The product is not non-sticky, meaning there are chances of food getting stuck to the pan when you get it out of the oven.

Pros
  • Stainless steel make and durable product
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher-safe
  • Allows healthier cooking
  • Has the dual function of broil and roast
Cons
  • The product is not nonstick
  1. Backcountry SKL-200

The Backcountry SKL-200 is a pan unlike any other. Made of cast iron, the pan works differently from regular broiler pans. At first glance, the pan looks like a hybrid of a skillet and broiler pan. This means that it retains all the qualities of both.

Backcountry Cast Iron 10" Medium Square Grill Pan...
  • Cast iron has superior heat retention for even cooking,...
  • Our 10” square pan has a few measurements you should know:...
  • Your black skillet can rust so keep it out of the...
  • Proudly designed in the USA, pre-seasoned with our...

Why Did We Like It?

The Backcountry SKL 200 is undoubtedly different from any broiler pans you may have used before. This makes it a part of a whole new league of its own. The pan comes with a number of features we liked quite a bit.

The pan has ribs that allow for quite a good sear on your seafood, meat, or even vegetables. The best thing about cast iron broiler pans is that they can be used on practically any cooking surface. This includes gas, induction, oven, grill, and even an open fire. We loved that this product has such versatility to it.

While the product works excellently for grilling and barbecuing, you don’t have to worry about additional grease in your cooking. The ribs on the surface do not allow fats to seep in, meaning they can be drained.

What Could’ve Been Better?

We loved the SKL 200 quite a bit and found just a tiny flaw. Since the pan is made from cast iron, you need to be careful about cleaning it with water because it can rust. That means the dishwasher isn’t a good idea and you need to take a lot of effort to clean it.

Pros
  • Can be used on any cooking surface
  • Does not need too much oil for cooking
  • Comfortable for use
  • Comes with a nonstick coating
Cons
  • Not dishwasher-safe
  1. Nordic 41831

The Nordic 41831 is another two-piece broiler pan that a lot of people would appreciate. The product is manufactured by Nordic Ware, which has a long history of producing good kitchenware. This product is well suited for broiling meat and vegetables.

Nordic Ware Broiler Pan, 2-Piece Set, Nonstick
  • 2-piece broiler pan set for broiling poultry, fish, or...
  • Includes ribbed broiling rack and a multi-purpose...
  • Measures 15 x 10 x 1 inches
  • Cooking Surface: L: 12.63 inch, W: 8.38 inch, H: 0.75 inch

Why Did We Like It?

There’s a lot of reasons to love the Nordic 41831. We love the fact that the product comes with two pieces, both of which suit your cooking purposes quite well. The broiling rack is ribbed, which allows the excess oil to be drained off. The structure also allows for even heat distribution throughout the pan.

The baking/dripping pan too can be used individually for cooking and lasts as long as the broiling rack. Along with the multi-purpose feature of the product, we love that both the rack and pan are non-sticky.

The nonstick feature is a great addition that we’ve already told you about. With this feature, you don’t have to worry about food getting stuck to the product. You also have the luxury of being able to clean the pan easier.

What Could’ve Been Better?

There’s quite a lot we liked about this broiler pan. But we did notice that though the pan is nonstick and can be cleaned easily, it is not dishwasher safe. This means you’ll have to clean the pan manually.

Pros
  • Allows for even heat distribution
  • Comes with a nonstick feature
  • Aluminized steel allows for durability
  • Does not need too much oil for cooking
Cons
  • Not dishwasher-safe
  1. TeamFar 8541905117

The TeamFar 8541905117 is unlike any broiler pan of the same category. It is made of the strongest stainless steel without any other coating added to it. It is quite beneficial for your day-to-day cooking. There’s much you’ll like about this broiler pan.

Sale
TeamFar Toaster Oven Tray and Rack Set, Stainless Steel...
  • HEALTHY - TeamFar toaster oven tray is made of 18/0...
  • CRAFT - This broiler pan has smooth rolled edges without...
  • EASY CLEAN - Full sides all around prevents sauce flowing...
  • WIRE RACK - The grill rack fits nicely inside the toaster...

Why Did We Like It?

We loved a lot of features of the TeamFar broiler pan. For one, it is rare to see a stainless steel broiler pan and the difference it makes is quite clear. The heat distribution on the pan is relatively even, allowing food to be cooked well.

In addition to this, the lack of chemical coating allows the food cooked to be healthier. The roasting rack is sturdy and allows the oils to drip through to the bottom tray without any issues. We also loved that the rack cooks the meat evenly due to its structure.

We talked about the broiler rack and the stainless steel pan. Let’s talk about the non-spill features of the dripping pan. The deeper walls and the smoother edges on the dripping pan are quite helpful, especially when there’s liquid on the pan that doesn’t spill over.

What Could’ve Been Better?

We told you everything that’s good about the pan. Now let’s talk about something that could have been better. While stainless steel is good, we think that cleaning it might be a little tougher task, especially tougher stains.

Pros
  • Even distribution of heat
  • Smoother edges and higher walls on dripping pan
  • Does not use too much oil
  • Durable and strong
Cons
  • Not too easy to clean
  1. Smart Choice 55926

The SmartChoice 55926 is a good choice if you’re looking for a broiling pan that suits your cooking needs well. It’s durable, sturdy, and has enough features that will help you get the cooking done without much of a hassle.

Basic Broiler Pan
  • Nonstick broiler pan for easy clean-up
  • Bottom tray can be used separately for roasting/baking
  • More even heat distribution
  • Works well with almost all ovens

Why Did We Like It?

The 55926 is a simple broiler pan that provides you with the basic cooking needs you might have. We loved that the pan is made of aluminum which gives you enough durability. It helps while you’re cooking heavier foods on the pan.

Along with aluminum, the top rack has a fine porcelain coating that is quite a relief for many. The coating provides you with the much-needed nonstick feature. It is especially useful if you want to clean your pan easily.

We loved the make and the finish of the pan. We also loved that the pan promotes healthy cooking. While cooking meat, the grease and oil from it drip onto the dripping pan beneath the rack. This gives you fat-free food.

What Could’ve Been Better?

We loved a lot of features of the product, but we felt that it lacked in one particular department. The pan does not seem to have enough strength because the corners get indents after a period.

Pros
  • Easy to clean
  • Promotes healthier cooking
  • Comes with nonstick features
  • Even heat distribution
Cons
  • Gets indents after a period
  1. G&S PB7992

The G&S PB7992, like most products from ProBake, is designed for smoother functioning within the kitchen. This broiler pan from G&S goes right back to the basics and is a fairly good addition to the kitchen. You’ll be able to use it comfortably because it is designed for day-to-day use.

G & S Metal Products Company ProBake Teflon Nonstick Bake,...
  • DESIGNED FOR HEALTHY COOKING: The ProBake bake, broil, and...
  • THREE-PIECE SET: Each set contains one 12.8” x 8.9” x...
  • NON-STICK FINISH: A Teflon nonstick finish keeps food from...
  • HEAVYWEIGHT STEEL CONSTRUCTION: The ProBake bake, broil, and...

Why Did We Like It?

There’s quite a lot you’ll love about this product. First of all, it doesn’t complicate things with too many features. The first thing you’ll like is its sturdiness that allows for cooking heavier meats like turkey.

The extra Teflon layer on this metal product is not just for ease of use. It is designed for nonstick cooking and easier cleaning. We would recommend you don’t use a metal spatula to stir the food around. This will help the Teflon layer last long.

We also loved that the three-piece cooking set provides enough accessories you need for oven-based cooking. The rack roasts meat effortlessly, while the baking pan and the roasting pan help bake desserts and roast smaller meat and vegetables.

What Could’ve Been Better?

While there’s a lot to like in this product, we found a minor flaw with it. The heavier metal is welcome, especially for cooking turkey; we did find that it can be a little too much at some other points and can be a little too heavy for daily use.

Pros
  • Teflon coating for nonstick cooking
  • Easy to clean
  • Durable and lasts longer
  • Three-piece product for multi-purpose cooking
Cons
  • Weight can be an issue sometimes
  1. Whirlpool 4396923

Like a few models in this category, the Whirlpool broiler pan is simple and gets the job done. The broiler pan works well for you if you have enough day-to-day cooking. It is light and easy to handle, allowing you to meal prep effortlessly. If you’re on the lookout for a newer broiler pan to replace an older model, this is a good pick for you.

KITCHEN BASICS 101 Replacement Porcelain Broiler Pan and...
  • Includes a pan and a bottom tray
  • Dimensions of pan and grid are 16.5" by 12.5"
  • Durable porcelain finish; Made in USA
  • Dishwasher safe; Works with most brands

Why Did We Like It?

The Whirlpool broiler pan has a number of features we liked. While the pan is not too heavy on features, it has enough that gets the job done. One of the most important features we loved was its two-piece equipment that works well for regular-day-to day cooking.

We loved the porcelain finish on the product. This means you can clean the aftermath of your cooking with little effort. It also means that even food doesn’t get stuck to your pan. Another advantage to this is that you can get rid of the fat and grease on the pan effortlessly.

The product has been manufactured to allow heat to flow through the pan easily. This means that you don’t need to worry about under-cooking or overcooking your food. You’ll also love that the dripping pan can be used as a baking tray as well.

What Could’ve Been Better?

There are enough features on this product that we liked. However, we did find a slight problem with the product. While you can cook regularly with the product, you need to be mindful of the heat flow. Too much of it can damage your pan faster.

Pros
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher-safe
  • Even heat distribution
  • Promotes healthier cooking
  • Comes with nonstick features
Cons
  • Not adaptable to excessive heat

Organic farm raw whole chicken in a pan. Black background. Top view.

Broiler Pan Buyer’s Guide

So, has our list given you an idea of which broiler pan you need? Choosing the right broiler pan is undoubtedly a confusing task. The sheer number of broiler pan models in the market can confuse you. The model, the material, and even the size matter when you select one.

If you are still confused, here are a few criteria that you need to remember before selecting a good broiler pan.

  1. Dimensions

The broiler pan’s dimensions matter more than you would think. The pan you finally choose must always be compatible with your oven’s size. In addition to this, ensure that the broiler pan you finally choose meets your cooking needs. If you consistently cook with larger meat like turkey or meal prep larger batches of food, then a strong broiler pan is the right pick.

On the other hand, if you cook exclusively for yourself, and the ingredients used are smaller in size and ratio, it is wiser to go for smaller brands. Either way, make sure to recognize your kitchen’s needs before making a decision.

  1. The Broiler Pan’s Features

Another important criterion that matters before choosing a broiler pan is its features. Some details like its surface and heating speed are quite important. You don’t want a broiler pan that consistently needs scrapping because food is stuck to it.

Along with that, a surface that takes time to heat food to all sides can be bothersome. Another aspect to take note of is the drip tray. The broiler pan must have holes that do not get clogged. More importantly, it should allow excessive oils to seep through effortlessly.

So, before selecting a broiler pan, always look out for these features. The surface must be user-friendly. Along with user-friendliness, the pan must be ergonomic and easy to handle. It needs to fulfill its purpose and allow for post-cooking tasks like cleaning and storage to be done easily.

  1. Versatility Of Use

Another important criterion that your broiler pan must meet is the versatility of use. For a person with limited accessories, while cooking, multi-purpose cookware is the way to go. These include instant pots and broiler pans.

Broiler pans that can double down as baking trays and grilling pans are quite handy. They serve the purpose you need them to while retaining their original usefulness as well. In addition to their versatility, you need to ensure that the pan you choose in the end is dishwasher safe as well. This will help make sure that cleaning is not a tiring task.

Raw organic chicken breastin grill pan on a grey background. Food preparation, top view

Verdict

Selecting a broiler pan is undoubtedly not as easy a task as you would expect. There are a number of factors you need to be aware of.

If you ask us which broiler pan we liked, we would definitely tell you that the Range Kleen BP106X is our pick. It is versatile and compact, and works well for regular day-to-day use.

We also liked the TeamFar 8541905117 and the General Electric WB48X10056. This is because both options give users a better range. The TeamFar product is made of stainless steel, which allows for durability. On the other hand, the General Electric broiler pan is simple and easy enough to use.

We hope you are able to make an informed decision regarding the broiler pan for your needs.

Do take a look at our options and select one that you whole-heartedly feel comfortable with.

We’ll see you soon with another guide. Have a nice day!

Related Articles

13 Best Electric Kettles Right Now | Buyer’s Guide

10 Best Food Scales Buyer’s Guide and Reviews

15 Best Electric Smokers – Guide & Budget Picks

13 Best Kitchen Shears Right Now Reviewed

13 Best Mini Freezers for a Chilly Year  

10 Best Hot Dog Rollers | Buyer’s Guide and Reviews

13 Best Cappuccino Makers to Enjoy Today | Buyer’s Guide

11 Best Range Hoods to Consider

11 Best Bar Stools Today | Buyer’s Guide and Reviews 

13 Best Wine Coolers Right Now

7 Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker  

7 Best Manual Meat Grinders 

13 Best Molcajete

8 Best Apple Peeler

11 Best Zoodle Maker

Read next

old grinder with minced meat and vegetables on wooden table

7 Best Manual Meat Grinders [Reviewed & Buyer’s Guide]

Because of the hot weather, the boy stood by the fan blowing cold air to his face.

LG Electronics LP0814WNR Portable Air Conditioner Reviewed

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *