Colored pencils are some of the most under-appreciated mediums of artistry. They are easy-to-use, inexpensive, versatile and can make some of the finest pieces of art.
Some artists think that colored pencil is an immature medium that is only meant for kids. But that is certainly not the case.
Many professional artists have created some of the best works of their life using these handy pencils. And while there are certainly inexpensive colored pencils for the casual, the market is also saturated with professional grade pencils.
So, today, in this discussion we are going to highlight some of our top picks of colored pencils for artists everywhere in the world – both professional and beginners alike.
So, without any further adieu, go ahead and give it a read!
Best Colored Pencils
- Best Colored Pencils
- Prismacolor Colored Pencils and Sets
- Derwent Colored Pencils ColourSoft
- Tombow Irojiten Color Pencils
- Koh-I-Noor Progresso Woodless Colored Pencils
- Faber-Castell Polychromos
- Caran d’Ache Luminance Colored Pencils
- LYRA Rembrandt Polycolor Art Pencils
- Stabilo CarbOthello Chalk-Pastel Colored Pencil
- Creative Art Materials Colored Pencils
- Holbein Artist Colored Pencils
- Blick Studio Artists’ Colored Pencils
- Related Articles
By far, one of the most popular brands in the world of colored pencils is Prismacolor. The reason behind their popularity is their price to performance value, even if some consider them to be on the pricier side. And with flexible size options, varying from 12 to 150 different colors in a single set, we absolutely fell in love it!
- Soft, thick cores are perfect for shading and shadows
- Light fast, richly saturated pigments
- Ultra smooth, even color laydown
- Thick, robust leads resist cracking and chipping
Even though these are wax-based colored pencils, like many others on this list, the performance is astoundingly good. The set that we used in our testing is one of the basic sets, but there are many other options to choose from as well.
The lead has a fairly high pigment count and even though these are wax-based pencils, the colors are significantly softer and blend more evenly than the other wax-based pencils we have used.
The colors are also very vibrant and no matter what color we used from the set, it looked attractive and gave results that are very close to something we’d expect from a professional grade pencil.
But even though the pencils have an excellent performance, arguably the best among all the other brands of wax-based colored pencils, we’d still not recommend it for professional use. Due to the lack of any lightfast rating, we don’t trust its permanence.
Overall, the pencils are a great value for money, with each color costing roughly $0.60, for any casual, beginner or even intermediate artist.
Derwent’s ColourSoft colored pencils perform remarkably well that honestly surprised us. With its soft core lead and vibrant colors, these pencils are so good that they can steal the heart of a professional.
While there are a few objectively better brands of colored pencils that professionals abide by, the value these pencils offer for the price is seriously astounding.
- VIBRANT COLOUR: With a round 4 millimeters soft core, the...
- SOFT TEXTURE: The velvety soft core helps emphasize the...
- DURABLE CORE: Break resistant core lets you sharpen pencils...
- COLOUR BLENDING: Due to their enhanced formulation, these...
The colors are incredibly lightfast and you can get the exact information of each color with the attractive color chart that is included in the box.
The lead is extremely soft and it produced some of the most vibrant colors we have seen when a pencil is put to paper. And the soft nature of the core also makes it excellent at blending and shading.
Some of us were worried that the soft core of the pencils will break often and will chip while sharpening but, fortunately enough, the lead is extremely resistant to breaking and there was no case where it broke off unexpectedly when we put pressure.
The lead, however, is a little on the thicker side – roughly, 4mm. While that is a problem for detailed work – because you’d need to constantly sharpen it, it proved excellent for blending and filling out the larger parts of the painting.
Overall, these pencils are excellent for professional grade use and they come at a fairly reasonable price unlike some other brands of similar quality and performance.
Tombow Irojiten is a Japanese company that manufactures some of the most unique art products that we have had our hands on. Their products have stolen the hearts of many artists since 1913 because of their impeccable quality and their quality of standing out in the market. And these colored pencils also stay faithful to their formula.
- Elegant enamel finish
- 90 unique colors
- Exquisite packaging
- 1 Pack includes all three sets (Vol 1-3 Rainforest, Vol 4-6...
The colors are vibrant, and the pigments are soft and produce an even tone, which is great for blending.
As for lightfastness and permanence, it seems to be excellent in that regard. But the sources we’ve used are not very reliable.
And these unique colors are packaged according to the palette instead of size. Because of that, you get sets like Cool Grey, Seascape, Woodlands, etc. And all of these sets have a different number of colors as well.
We found this on the favorable side because you can just buy colors on the basis of the piece you are doing. If you are doing an art piece with Earth shades, then you can just go ahead and buy only those.
But this argument becomes a little redundant because the pencils are also sold individually but with an extra charge.
They also have many unfamiliar shades and colors that we hadn’t experienced before. So, if you are looking for bringing some newness to your artworks, then you have found your match!
Koh-I-Noor Progresso Woodless Colored Pencils redefine the fundamentals of a pencil at an extremely inexpensive price point. And yes, you head that right! These pencils are indeed made without wood. These are just leads that are wrapped in lacquer. The result of which is positively interesting.
- Rich, pigmented, solid color encased in lacquer
- Five times the color as wood-cased pencils
- Excellent laydown properties for layering and blending...
- Create dense, even strokes without the use of heavy pressure
Since the pencils are all-lead, you can toggle between fine lines and broad strokes with just a slight movement making it extremely flexible to use. Filling out large areas also become way easier.
In our experience, we couldn’t help but draw parallels between brushes and these pencils. And don’t worry, the lacquer covering is great at preventing the colors from spreading and making it all messy.
In terms of performance as well these pencils do remarkably well. The colors are vibrant and the pigment density is enough to provide softness to the colors, which is great for blending purposes.
There are two gripes that we have with this color set though. One is the lack of color chart and lightfast ratings and another is the inability to be bought individually.
But when each pencil costs about only $0.58, we couldn’t hold any grudges against it.
Overall, these pencils have a unique feature that we haven’t witnessed in other brands before. And although we would not deem it fit for professional work, we consider it an excellent product for any other use case.
Faber-Castell is a company that needs no introduction in the art community. They make some of the best quality art products that artists all around the globe abide by.
Their oil-based Polychromos colored pencils constitute one of those fine specimens. These pencils check all the boxes of an excellent colored pencil set and offer interesting advantages over other wax-based colored pencils.
- 120 COLORS IN METAL TIN - Includes all colors from the...
- UNSURPASSED LIGHTFASTNESS - Each Polychromos pencils...
- EASY TO BLEND - Buttery smooth color laydown, Polychromos...
- BREAK RESISTANT LEADS - Polychromos Pencils feature thick...
These are oil based pencils and these are extremely reminiscent of oil pastels or oil colors in terms of flow and how the colors behave. So, it’s way smoother than wax-based colored pencils which makes it better at blending.
Oil-based colored pencils are not that common – as evident from the abundance of wax-based pencils on our list as well. Other than being better blending, these pencils are also resistant to water and since oil is a stronger binder, the lead is way less prone to breaking or chipping.
As for the performance of these pencils specifically, the colors are well saturated and behave consistently. And the lightfastness is absolutely amazing! Hence, we deem is fit for professional use.
The pencils also have a thicker core – about 3.8 mm – so, you get a wider range of strokes capable of both detailing and blunt blending.
Overall, these are excellent oil-based pencils that are great for almost any kind of artist, even though the slick feeling is a departure from more popular wax-based colored pencils. And if you are unsatisfied with wax-based pencils, then surely give these a try!
There are some brands in the art supplies industry that represent the state of the art. These brands don’t care about compromises for a smaller price tag. All they aim to do is to make the best product possible to cater to the needs of professionals all around the world. Caran d’Ache is one of those companies and their colored pencils exhibit that commitment as well.
- High lightfastness and smoothness
- Swiss made
- 76 piece assortment
- Can be blended and layered for various effects
These pencils are at the top of the ladder. The finest pencils a professional can lay a had on.
The pencils feature thick 8 mm lead cores that can be sharpened to the finest tip possible and they’d still not break or chip. Of course, this provides a wide variety of strokes that’d not be otherwise possible.
They also surpass any other colored pencils in terms of lightfastness and permanence. Over 80% of their pencils belong to class I of lightfastness, that means they will remain unhindered for over 100 years. And the remaining colors belong to class II, meaning they will maintain their luster for 50 to 100 years.
The colors are also impeccably good-looking and the pencils flow smoothly no matter what kind of paper we used. And blending is also jaw-droppingly graceful.
Of course, the best of the bests will also be valued at a similar price point but that would never be a problem for a professional who is making a living from the quality of these pencils.
And you can get these pencils in 5 different set sizes.
A fair competition to Faber-Castell Polychromos colored pencils set is LYRA Rembrandt Polycolor Art Pencils. These are also oil-based colored pencils but these offer a different set of pros & cons compared to the aforementioned brand.
But that doesn’t change the fact that these pencils are of excellent quality as well and hence, they are worthy of competition.
- Use for graphics, design and art
- Metal box container
- Brilliant, light fast, and water resistant
- Smooth lead
Like the Polychromos, these pencils also flow incredibly smooth and blend effortlessly as well. The colors also perform outstandingly in therms vibrancy and vividity. The pigments can also be manipulated with turpentine or any odorless mineral spirit.
The purchase options for these pencils are also very lucrative. You can buy these in 5 different size options – 12, 24, 36, 72 and 105. But the best part is that you can any pencil individually, which is great news for professional artists.
What’s not so great though is that the pencils don’t come with a color chart and that’s not suitable for many professionals.
When compared to Polychromos, these pencils are indeed a little more affordable but still fall on the expensive side of the spectrum with each pencil costing roughly $1.33 when bought in a set of 24.
Some artists have complained online that the lead chips and breaks but we never had such experience. Hence, we also recommend using manual sharpeners with these pencils instead of electric ones.
All of the colors we have talked until now were either wax-based or oil-based colors. But we wanted to vary this list with an entry from Stabilo CarbOthello. These pencils are chalk-pastel and they bring a fairly unique experience on the table, fundamentally different from all the other entries on this list.
- Pastel pencils for both fine and commercial artists
- 4.4 mm lead diameter
- 60 colors
Chalk-pastel colored pencils are significantly different in experience from conventional colored pencils based on wax or oil. The powdery nature of the colors makes blending way more fun.
These pencils belong to the premium category and hence, are followed by a matching price tag.
The pigments are of top-notch quality, and they are smooth and vibrant. The colors blend together extremely well and with a mix and match of different kinds of paper, you might just witness a unique artwork that’d not have been possible with any other brand of pencils.
As for lightfastness, these colors are extremely resistant to fading due to light and it defines the premium nature of these pencils. So, we think that if you love the experience and the results you get from these pencils, then don’t be afraid to use it for professional artwork.
The pigments are also partially aquarellable, meaning that you can use these pencils with brush and water, and the contours of your artwork will remain intact. And the range of colors in the set is quite satisfactory too with 60 different colors.
An extremely unique way to use colored pencils is by using it in a combination with other mediums, especially, watercolors. For those who are looking for colored pencils capable of such artistry, we have brought you Creative Art’s Materials colored pencils.
- Use hexagonal pencils wet or dry
- Metal box set of 40
- Exceptional covering power and superb lightfastness
While we have had some other oil-based pencils on this list like Polychromos and Lyra, these pencils are better for mixed media because these are significantly softer and silkier than other oil-based colored pencils.
Hence, the pigments latch on to the paper better and the result is more vibrant colors and expressiveness when used alongside other mediums like watercolor.
Other than that, this set of colored pencils behave pretty much similar to any other oil-based colored pencil. Its feeling is silky and the blends are more realistic than the ones created with waxed-based colors.
The durability of the lead is also better than wax-based pencils because oil is a stronger binder. There will be no chipping or breaking after sharpening.
Along with all these redeeming features, the lead is also sufficiently thick. This allows a wider range of strokes.
And the colors are fairly lightfast as well, which makes it capable of being used in a professional project.
Overall, it’s an outstanding colored pencil set like its other oil-based siblings. And its soft lead also makes it the best choice for mixed media.
Holbein Artist Colored Pencils
Holbein Artist Colored Pencils is one of the most elaborate sets of colored pencils that we have seen that comes at an affordable price point. Even though the 150 different shades of colors steal the show, the pencils themselves are of remarkable quality and perform quite magnificently.
No products found.
The number of colors that you get in a box can be quite overwhelming. When you get 150 different shades of colors stacked in two layers of a box, you don’t really have room to complain.
We deem it the most comprehensive set of colors for a beginner and casual artist. As for performance, the colors are quite excellent as the pigments are saturated and blend excellently.
The lightfastness and the permanence of the colors are also quite satisfactory. Although we don’t recommend this to professional artists who need it to pitch perfect.
We’ll rate these colors well above average in terms of performance, meaning that it’s superb enough to deal with the needs of most artists until it’s some serious business.
One thing that was pleasing for us to note, was the thickness of the lead. It’s 3.8 mm and since it’s on the thicker side, you get a wider range of strokes.
Overall, it’s an excellent colored pencil set for casual, beginner and even intermediate artists. But unfortunately, the lightfastness of these colors makes them fall short for any professional use.
Blick is one of the most beloved brands in this industry. They have found a perfect balance of price-to-performance that seems to please a lot of artists all around the world. And to no surprise, Blick does it again with their colored pencils as well.
These are the perfect middle-of-the-ground pencils that are priced in a beginner friendly fashion but perform like a professional-grade tool.
Right off the bat, the performance matches and even rivals some of the professional-grade pencils that are way more expensive than these ones.
The colors are vibrant and they blend extremely easily. The pigment density is also high.
And the best part is that your artworks will maintain their luster for years to come because the colors are incredibly lightfast. Nothing about the performance felt short, especially, when considering the price.
And the purchase options are incredibly flexible too. First, these are 5 different sizes you can buy – 12, 24, 36, 48 and 72. If that doesn’t suit you, you can also buy them in thematic sets called Greys, Landscape, and Portrait. And if that doesn’t feel right to you, then you can also purchase them individually!
So, if you looking to move on from rudimentary colored pencils and get into some serious works of art, there is no better option than this. And once you do move on, you won’t change soon because these are nearly gems.
So that’ll be all for this piece.
Hope you enjoyed our list and enjoy the products as much as we did. We also tried to make each entry as unique as possible to cater to different needs.
With that, we wish you very well on your creative journey and thank you for reading!